Written By: David Cosseboom | Updated On: October 30th, 2025
Key Takeaways
- Constellation, Energy Harbor, and Frontier Utilities lead the pack for value, stability, and overall customer satisfaction in Ohio.
- If you want simple, worry-free fixed rates, Public Power and APG&E are strong choices, while CleanSky Energy is great for affordable 100% renewable power.
- Deal-hunters may like Clearview Energy or Santanna Energy Services, but renewal terms require active monitoring to avoid price jumps.
- Your utility (AEP Ohio, AES Ohio, Duke, or FirstEnergy companies) still manages outages and delivery, what really matters is the supply rate, fees, and contract terms you choose.
Shopping for an electric supplier in Ohio can feel overwhelming, especially with dozens of options, promo rates, fine-print fees, and contract terms that all look similar at a glance. The good news is that Ohio’s deregulated electricity market gives you the freedom to choose a plan that fits your budget, lifestyle, and preferences, whether you want the lowest fixed rate, cleaner energy, better customer service, or simple “set-it-and-forget-it” billing. To help you cut through the noise, we evaluated each supplier using real customer feedback, pricing competitiveness, BBB ratings, plan transparency, and fee structures. Below, you’ll find our top picks and who each provider is best suited for, so you can switch with confidence and avoid any surprises on your monthly bill.
Top 10 Electric Suppliers in Ohio (2025)
#1 Constellation
4.7/5
- Rates From 9.79¢ /kWh
- 90 Day Satisfaction Guarantee
- Lock in Rates for 3-36 Months
Best for: Worry-free switching & solid fixed-rate value
Constellation consistently posts competitive fixed-rate offers in Ohio and stands out with a 90-day satisfaction guarantee that reduces “buyer’s remorse” risk if a plan isn’t the right fit. In our price sampling, Constellation’s plans regularly landed near the front of the pack, and the company’s long track record and parent-company scale add stability.
They also market simple, no-gimmick residential plans statewide (Columbus, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Toledo, Akron/Youngstown territories), which helps them earn high marks for transparency and plan breadth.
We ranked Constellation at the top of our list because they consistently offer competitive fixed-rate pricing, clear fee terms, a strong BBB profile, and fewer complaint patterns around renewals and billing than peers.
What Ohio customers are saying: Ohio residents generally like that Constellation delivers exactly what they sign up for, steady fixed rates and no surprises. Positive comments mention clear disclosures, smooth first bills, and quick transfers from utility default service. A few folks note that rates can sit slightly above the absolute lowest promo, but the trade-off for reliability and transparency feels worth it. Great reviews often come from customers who’ve stayed multiple terms and avoided sudden jumps.
#2 Energy Harbor
Best for: Long-term, carbon-free fixed rates with an Ohio focus
Headquartered in Ohio, Energy Harbor offers carbon-free electricity options with straightforward fixed terms, popular with shoppers who want price stability and lower-emissions power. They’re active across FirstEnergy service areas (Ohio Edison, The Illuminating Company, Toledo Edison), and their Ohio footprint plus A+ BBB rating boosted their stability and trust scores.
Price positioning was consistently competitive in our PUCO spot-checks, and the local focus and brand familiarity across Ohio communities help with customer confidence.
Energy Harbor landed at #2 because they are a homegrown Ohio brand with strong trust signals, popular carbon-free products, and competitive long-term value. Just a hair behind Constellation on consistency in complaint trends.
What Ohio customers are saying: People often choose Energy Harbor because they’re local and support carbon-free energy, that resonates strongly in Ohio communities. Many say their fixed rates stay competitive even through seasonal pricing shifts. The main watch out noted in forums is renewal vigilance, customers who forget to re-shop occasionally find pricing creeping above market. Those who calendar renewals report very smooth experiences.
#3 Frontier Utilities
Best for: Straightforward fixed rates with simple terms
Frontier sells Ohio fixed-rate plans through its Midwest/Northeast arm and is certified as a CRES supplier; we saw straightforward plans that compete well against utility “price-to-compare” in many ZIPs. Recent Ohio plan roundups also highlight easily understood offers, which helped Frontier’s Fees & Fine Print and Plan Options scores.
Customer-review sentiment is mixed-to-positive in Ohio aggregator sites, and the brand’s expansion beyond Texas has matured, though support experiences can still vary by utility territory.
They landed at #3 due to their good value versus utility standard pricing and clear disclosures boosting Frontier high; a few mixed service reviews kept it behind the top two.
What Ohio customers are saying: Ohio reviews highlight simple enrollment and deals that beat the Price-to-Compare in major utility zones. Customers like knowing they aren’t dealing with gimmicks or tricky tiered rates. The mixed feedback usually relates to support response times when billing questions pop up. If everything goes to plan, satisfaction is high, issues arise mainly for those who need help mid-contract.
#4 Public Power
Best for: “Set-it-and-forget-it” simple fixed rates
Public Power serves multiple deregulated states, including Ohio, with steady fixed-rate offers and a straightforward value prop. Their current BBB rating is A+, which helped credibility and complaint-risk scoring in our model.
PUCO listings show them active on Apples-to-Apples; plan pricing isn’t always the lowest, but terms are clear and stable, good for shoppers who prize predictability over chasing the rock-bottom teaser.
Public Power’s excellent BBB standing and low complaint intensity gave Public Power a boost, though pricing is occasionally mid-pack vs. leaders and landed them at the #4 spot.
What Ohio customers are saying: Ohio shoppers like how predictable Public Power plans are, solid pricing, straight fixed rates, and few hidden extras. Their A+ BBB trust credentials come up a lot in positive feedback. Some critiques mention that promotional rates aren’t always the lowest on Apples-to-Apples, but for customers prioritizing stability over chasing the bottom rate, the experience is typically pleasant and low-stress.
#5 APG&E
Best for: Hands-on customer service & longer fixed-term value
APG&E operates in Ohio with fixed-rate residential plans and touts an A+ BBB rating. Our scans found decent value on longer terms and plain-English disclosures that scored well for Fees & Fine Print.
Pricing is competitive (rarely the absolute lowest), but APG&E’s service posture and stability nudged them into the top half. Ohio pages and plan funnels reinforce a “no-nonsense” sign-up flow, improving order-experience sentiment.
APG&E’s A+ BBB rating and strong renewal transparency helped APG&E land in the top half, even though pricing isn’t always the lowest.
What Ohio customers are saying: Many Ohio customers mention easy enrollment and personable support when they need help. Fixed-rate customers tend to stay satisfied throughout their term. Concerns come mostly from people who miss renewal notices, similar to others, renewal pricing can jump from intro rates. But sentiment trends positive when customers stay engaged and shop before the contract switches to a variable rate.
#6 CleanSky Energy
Best for: 100% renewable electricity at approachable rates
CleanSky sells 100% renewable power in Ohio, with straightforward switching and frequent promo pricing that undercuts many green competitors. They’re also listed among registered suppliers for AES Ohio service areas, supporting statewide availability.
Forum sentiment can be mixed (as with most suppliers), but CleanSky’s green positioning, simple product set, and budget-friendly options net them a strong niche score for eco-shoppers.
CleanSky ended up in the 6 spot due to their affordable clean-energy offers and clear green claims which helped them score well; mildly mixed support reviews kept them mid-table.
What Ohio customers are saying: Customers attracted to cleaner electricity are generally pleased, reviews often say CleanSky made going green feel affordable and straightforward. Folks like that rates are easy to compare and branding is transparent. Complaints tend to center around app expectations or billing synchronization when switching utility territories. Overall, sentiment is “good value if you want renewable power without the premium.”
#7 Santanna Energy Services
3.9/5
- Rates From 10.1¢ /kWh
- 90 Day Satisfaction Guarantee
- Lock in Rates for 12 Months
Best for: Predictable bills & flexible “earth-friendly” add-ons
Santanna offers Ohio fixed-rate and “earth-friendly” electricity options and actively markets in larger metros like Cleveland and Columbus. Third-party plan roundups show competitive terms; overall sentiment is mixed but trending OK when customers stay on fixed rates and track renewals.
We did note forum complaints tied to post-promo renewals and monthly fees, good reminders to calendar your end date and re-shop before a plan rolls over.
Competitive plans and a positive reputation in parts of Ohio, but renewal surprises and fee complaints lower the score and leave Santanna in the #7 spot.
What Ohio customers are saying: Ohio feedback describes Santanna as “solid when you lock into the right plan.” People like that they can choose greener options or bill-friendly terms. But review patterns show rate creep after promos, especially if customers don’t shop renewals. Those who stay proactive usually report a predictable and easy relationship; those who forget sometimes end up frustrated.
#8 Clearview Energy
Best for: Short-term deals if you’re a diligent re-shopper
Clearview sells in Ohio (e.g., Duke/AES territories) and often posts aggressive intro rates; the brand carries an A+ BBB rating, which helps on the trust front.
However, customer-review sentiment is very mixed, especially on renewals, so we recommend Clearview for shoppers who actively manage their plan and don’t mind switching again if a renewal lands above market.
Clearview Energy landed in the #8 because their aggressive intro pricing earned strong value marks, but significant renewal-related complaints dragged down Customer Experience.
What Ohio customers are saying: The most common Ohio sentiment: “good deal early, watch the renewal.” People appreciate aggressive intro pricing and the A+ BBB backing. But many forum posts warn that pricing can shift noticeably after the first term. The best experiences come from customers who love to shop often and keep an eye on their contract end date.
#9 Direct Energy
Best for: Bundled home services/perks with lots of plan choices
Direct Energy is a major national supplier active in Ohio with a wide menu of fixed terms and add-on perks. That breadth boosts their Plan Options score, and pricing is often mid-pack.
On the flip side, the BBB profile for Direct shows a C- rating and a pattern of complaints, which weighed down Customer Experience in our model. If you prioritize features/perks and don’t mind keeping receipts and contacting support quickly when problems pop up, Direct can still be a fit.
Direct Energy’s huge plan variety and solid pricing couldn’t offset poor BBB standing and elevated complaint trends around billing & service putting them in our list at #9.
What Ohio customers are saying: Direct Energy earns praise for bundles, perks, and app features, homeowners who like add-ons are often happy. On the other hand, Ohio-specific complaints point to support delays, proactive fees, or clarity issues when something unexpected appears on a bill. The happiest customers tend to be those who monitor account changes and make use of customer service quickly if anything looks off.
#10 Provision Power & Gas
Best for: Carbon-offset extras & tree-planting “feel-good” plans
Provision focuses on CarbonBetter® energy in Ohio (100% clean energy, plus tree-planting), which is unique and scored well for Transparency & Stability given the clear environmental disclosures.
That said, Ohio-specific customer-review sentiment is middling on aggregator sites, mainly around support responsiveness. If climate impact is your first filter and you value zero-ETF simplicity, Provision is a neat niche choice.
Provision’s strong Transparency score thanks to CarbonBetter® and climate claims, but middling Ohio support sentiment keeps them at the bottom of the top 10.
What Ohio customers are saying: Sentiment here is niche but positive, people who like the climate benefits feel great about the choice. Tree-planting and carbon-offset messaging gets kudos. The critical reviews mostly flag slow follow-ups from customer service or uncertainty about what’s included in the clean-energy premium. Those who value the mission above everything else are usually satisfied.
Honorable Mentions
- Think Energy: Clean-energy-forward marketing and active Ohio offers, but very mixed recent review sentiment pulled the score just below the line this cycle. If you like their approach, compare their current rate against your utility’s Price-to-Compare and set a renewal reminder.
- American Power & Gas: Shows A+ BBB at the corporate level, but we found limited Ohio-specific momentum versus peers in our spot-checks; worth checking out if promo rates improve.
How we built this ranking (methodology)
- Framework & weights: Price & Value (35%), Customer Experience (25%) (BBB rating/complaint patterns, Ohio-specific review sites, Reddit/local forums), Plan Options (15%), Fees & Fine Print (15%) (ETF, monthly fees, renewal language), and Transparency & Stability (10%) (BBB standing, certifications, clear environmental claims).
- Sources & sample size (this Ohio run): 28 public sources reviewed and ~120 Ohio-specific reviews/forum posts read between Aug–Oct 2025. Key sources included PUCO Apples-to-Apples (to benchmark pricing competitiveness on 10/28/2025), BBB business profiles/complaints pages, AES Ohio’s registered supplier list, vendor Ohio landing pages, and Ohio-focused plan/ratings aggregators.
- Pricing view: We did not lock on a single “best price”; we compared each brand’s typical fixed-rate offers (12–24 months) against each utility’s “Price to Compare” during our sample window to inform relative value. Always check Apples-to-Apples for your exact ZIP before enrolling.
- Limitations & tie-breakers: Where Ohio-specific data was thin, we weighted state-level (OH) reviews over national ones and preferred recent sentiment (≤12 months). Close scores were broken by clearer fee terms and renewal transparency.
See our full Methodology for Rating Electric Suppliers
Quick Ohio Shopping Tips
- Start with your utility’s Price-to-Compare and filter to 12–24-month fixed plans.
- Scan fees & renewals (ETF, monthly fees, and what happens at term end).
- Calendar a reminder 30–45 days before your contract ends to avoid roll-to-variable surprises (a common complaint theme across multiple brands).
FAQs About Electricity Suppliers in Ohio
How does electricity choice work in Ohio?
What is the “Price to Compare”?
Is switching suppliers safe and reliable?
Are there any fees to switch?
• ETF policies
• Monthly service fees
• Renewal terms
• Promo conditions
A plan with a rock-bottom intro rate can cost more long-term if it has hidden fees or steep renewal pricing.
Should I choose a fixed or variable rate?
Variable rates can change monthly and often rise after promos, so we recommend them only if you actively monitor the market.
What happens when my contract ends?
Can I get renewable or carbon-free energy in Ohio?
About the Author
David has been an integral part of some of the biggest utility sites on the internet, including InMyArea.com, HighSpeedInternet.com, BroadbandNow.com, and U.S. News. He brings over 15 years of experience writing about, compiling and analyzing utility data.